Skip to main content

(2025) All Malaysia Reports (AMR) - Week 5

/
Content updates

Recently added cases from AMR to Westlaw Asia

Yong Kok Yeap v Precious Concrete Sdn Bhd [2025] 1 AMR 581, CA

Civil procedure – Summary judgment – Appeal – Claim for outstanding dues under contract – Joint and several guarantee executed by company's director ("guarantor") for any payment due and owing by company – Application for summary judgment allowed – Whether triable issues raised – Whether there was cause of action against guarantor – Whether guarantee binding on guarantor – Whether appeal ought to be allowed – Rules of Court 2012, Order 14

ZMSB v PSB [2025] 1 AMR 592, CA

Arbitration – Arbitration agreement – Appointment of arbitrator – Appellant alleged non-compliance with arbitrator's appointment procedure under agreement – Respondent countered non-compliance of timeframe stipulated in Arbitration Act 2005 ("AA") – Application to set aside arbitrator's award dismissed and application to enforce the same allowed – Whether procedure for challenging arbitrator's appointment under s 15 of the AA complied with – Whether failure to object to arbitrator's appointment within time stipulated in the AA constituted a waiver of right to object – Whether appellant may reserve its right to have challenge to arbitrator's appointment decided when award issued – Whether arbitration award could be set aside on basis of tribunal composition – Arbitration Act 2005, ss 7, 14(3)(a), (b), 15, 15(1), 37, 37(1)(a)(vi)

Loo Bee Eng v Pan Kee Mun & 5 Ors [2025] 1 AMR 611, HC

Civil procedure – Striking out – Application for – Declarations sought in suit similar to previously dismissed originating summons ("OS") – No appeal filed against said dismissal – Whether facts pleaded and reliefs sought in suit similar to OS – Whether suit frivolous and vexatious and abuse of court's process – Whether suit barred by res judicata or estoppel – Whether merits of suit considered in OS – Rules of Court 2012, Order 18 r 19

MFS Sdn Bhd v P Vivekananda a/l Paniarasalam [2025] 1 AMR 632, HC

Contract – Moneylending agreement – Breach – Claim for recovery of monies loaned with interest – Claim dismissed solely due to non-compliance with s 21 of the Moneylenders Act 1951 ("the MA 1951") – Writ and statement of claim not accompanied by statement of account – Whether fatal to claim – Whether non-compliance with the MA 1951 must be pleaded – Whether plaintiff prejudiced – Whether plaintiff entitled to restitution – Contracts Act 1950, s 66 – Moneylenders Act 1951, ss 19, 21 – Rules of Court 2012

Michael Ding Soon Ming v Meor Wazir bin Zulaidin & 2 Ors (and Another Originating Summons) [2025] 1 AMR 657, HC

Land law – Caveats – Removal – First caveat lodged by purchaser on ground of execution of offer to purchase property and payment of earnest deposit – Second caveat lodged on same grounds with additional fact of pendency of suit for specific performance filed by him – Application to extend validity of first caveat filed by purchaser – Application to cancel second caveat filed by vendors – Whether first and second caveat separate – Whether second caveat valid when lodged – Which application ought to be allowed – National Land Code, ss 322-329, 323(2), 326, 326(1B), (2), (3), Form 19C

Perusahaan Otomobil Kedua Sdn Bhd & Anor v Lee Lap Kee (sole proprietor of and trading as Eco Auto Supply) [2025] 1 AMR 676, HC

Damages (General) – Assessment – Application for – Claim for trademark infringement and tort of passing off – Consent judgment entered by parties provided inquiry as to damages arising from acts of infringement or passing off may be carried out – Denial of liability despite consent judgment being entered – Whether said denial acceptable – Whether loss of business profits and loss of goodwill and reputation proven – Whether caused by defendant – Trade Descriptions Act 2011

Intellectual property – Trademarks – Infringement – Assessment of damages – Claim for trademark infringement and tort of passing off – Consent judgment entered by parties provided inquiry as to damages arising from acts of infringement or passing off may be carried out – Denial of liability despite consent judgment being entered – Whether said denial acceptable – Whether loss of business profits and loss of goodwill and reputation proven – Whether caused by defendant – Trade Descriptions Act 2011

Saravana Kumar a/l Kannu v Public Prosecutor [2025] 1 AMR 692, HC

Criminal law – Offences affecting the human body – Voluntarily causing grievous hurt by dangerous weapons – Appeal against conviction and sentence – Appellant allegedly wielding "parang" during commission of robbery and causing injury to victim – Defence primarily based on inability to grip weapon due to past injuries – Failure by prosecution to investigate said condition – Whether sufficient ground to allow appeal – Whether appellant's photo shown to victim prior to identification parade – Whether identification parade, photographic and dock identification flawed – Whether reliable to support conviction – Whether Sessions Court judge erred in rejecting defence of alibi solely due to familial relationship between appellant and his witnesses – Evidence Act 1950, s 114(g)

 

By Thomson Reuters Malaysia Editorial Team
Malaysia Editorial Team

Speak to a consultant

Can't find an answer to your question?
Contact our support team.

Request training

Contact our team to arrange training.

Tell us what you think

We'd love to hear what you think
of our products and support.